DSA NORTH STAR
  • Welcome
  • Principles
  • Join Us
  • Our Strategy
  • Blog
  • About
    • About North Star
    • About DSA
    • Contact
  • Welcome
  • Principles
  • Join Us
  • Our Strategy
  • Blog
  • About
    • About North Star
    • About DSA
    • Contact
. 

DSA North Star Caucus blog

North Star's Role in DSA: What Is to be done?

10/12/2021

4 Comments

 
What role should North Star DSA play in DSA? What objectives should we be pursuing? In discussing this question, the Steering Committee came to the view that it would be best, at this point in our history, to have a robust discussion of what that role and those objectives should be amongst everyone in our group. We thought that it was important to have a perspective that was broadly understood amongst us, which could only be achieved by involving more of us in the conversation, and we thought that with the many decades of experience that our group has, the conversation would be far richer by including more voices.
A conversation like this can go in many directions, not all of which are constructive, so we want to set a few parameters. First, if parts of the conversation become tangential to the main purpose here (as sometimes happens on our Google group list serve {-;) we will move them to their own separate thread, where they can continue without consuming or derailing the main conversation. Second, we would like the conversation to be grounded, rather than to devolve into a discussion of theory which is abstract and general, or become a discussion of broad principles that do not readily translate into ‘what is to be done.’ To that end, we should suggest a number of guiding questions:

  • What is the defining characteristic(s) of our current political moment?
  • Given this political moment, what are the tasks of the left and DSA?
  • What political strategies and approaches are best aligned with meeting these tasks?
  • What are the strengths and weaknesses of DSA, in terms of its understanding of the political moment and the tasks it poses, and in terms of the political strategies and approaches that are best aligned with meeting these tasks?
  • How should we act and intervene within DSA to build on its strengths and addresses its weaknesses?
 
We would like to commence this conversation with a contribution from Leo Casey. It is written in the form of six theses, so the argument is broken up into discrete points with which you may agree, disagree, or conclude that something vital is missing. The purpose of presenting this argument in the form of theses is that it will allow members to be precise about their agreement or disagreement with its different component parts.
 
If you decide that you would like to present your own set of theses, feel free to do so on our list serve.  If you decide that you would like to respond to Leo’s theses or to someone else’s points, we would like to suggest some ways to do so.
  • If you agree, don’t just say ‘I agree,’ but explain why you agree and what you conclude from your agreement.
  • If you disagree, don’t just say ‘I disagree,’ but explain why you disagree and what different political direction your disagreement would take North Star DSA.
  • If you think something is missing, make a case why it is not just an additional point that would make the argument more precise or elaborate, but something really essential that speaks directly to how we should intervene in DSA.

Duane Campbell for the North Star Steering Committee
 
With that, here is Leo’s opening contribution:

Six Theses:
 Leo Casey
 
1.     What defines the current political movement in the U.S. is the imminent danger of a right-wing racist and authoritarian movement seizing state power, with the loss of what remains of American democracy. This movement – which must be properly called neo-fascist – has already captured one of the two major political parties, and it is now laying the groundwork for overturning democratic elections in which it is defeated. What is now taking place in state capitols across the country are efforts to ensure that when the next time elections are held, voter suppression and gerrymandering will make it more difficult for anti-fascist forces to win, and that when the results still go against the neo-fascist candidates, they will be overturned. Successful coup d’états often follow failed ones, and these efforts are based on an analysis of why the attempted long coup d’état that took place in the aftermath of the 2020 election, culminating with the January 6th insurrection, failed – the objective is to eliminate obstacles to the victory of the next neo-fascist coup d’état.
 
2.     The political imperative of this moment, therefore, is the defeat of this neo-fascist movement. If it is not defeated, and if consequently what remains of American democracy is lost, all else – the labor movement, the struggles against racism, sexism, anti-queer bigotry, Islamophobia, anti-Semitism, and anti-immigrant prejudice, the battle against climate change and on behalf of democratic rights of free expression, a free media, and the rule of law – is lost with it. The organized left – including DSA – is part of what will be lost. This is a political moment of truth that the U.S. has not seen since the Civil War and the struggle to end slavery.
 
3.     To accomplish this political imperative of defeating neo-fascism, the broadest possible left-center coalition must be organized, uniting all who would defend democratic rule, regardless of other issues on which we will disagree. There is no more serious error in this political moment than the sectarian error of identifying centrist forces that must be included in this coalition as the main political enemy of the left, either rhetorically or in practice. This coalition will be stronger, and more politically foresighted, to the extent that the left is hegemonic within it, but we should conceive that role as one of political leadership in coalition, not as excluding centrist forces and narrowing the base of the democratic coalition.
 
4.     In the U.S., there is a broad mass left (most significantly, the labor movement, civil rights and anti-racist movements, women’s movement, LGBTQ movement, immigrant rights movement, religious progressives, community organizing movement and environmental movement) and a much smaller organized left (organizations established around an explicitly left politics, such as DSA, Working Families Party, Justice Democrats, MoveOn, Indivisible, Our Revolution, and various socialist groups.) The organized left in the U.S. has historically been weak, marked by the failure to develop a mass labor or social democratic political party, but it can – and should – play a role in the mobilization of the broad left and the organization of a broad center-left coalition for democracy. Indeed, there are political opportunities in playing that role – in many countries, the left has often grown into a more significant force when it has played an active leadership role in a broad front against fascism.
 
5.     As a result of its growth over the last five years, DSA has the most potential of the groups on the organized left – it has more members and more activists than the other groups, and has had real political victories in recent years, especially in electoral politics, not just the failures that have historically defined the socialist left in the U.S. But it is being held back by:
  • an inability to fully recognize that the main danger of the political moment lies in the neo-fascist movement, an inability which is expressed in its practical tendency to see centrists as a political foe equal to that of the right (the hesitancy and/or unwillingness to call for a vote for Biden-Harris in 2020, and the stance of only supporting openly democratic socialist candidates and members for office);
  • a sectarian disposition that fails to understand how DSA’s growth and current strengths came primarily out of coalition efforts in electoral politics (most especially around the Bernie Sanders campaigns, the AOC victory and the development of ‘the squad’ in Congress) and out of broad opposition to Trump and the rise of neo-fascism; instead, it overestimates its power in terms of its own internal organizational capacity. This disposition leads to a ‘go it alone’ approach that devalues and disparages coalition work with others on the organized left, and to an obliviousness of the importance – indeed, the necessity – of a broad center-left coalition to oppose neo-fascism;
  • the heritage of political marginality in an U.S. socialist movement that has too often defined itself not around what it could accomplish politically, but around fidelity to a set of political dogmas, such that actual political breakthroughs – even on the small scale of electing five open democratic socialists to the U.S. Congress – are treated with suspicion and even hostility, as little more than openings for betrayal of political principle. This heritage finds expression in a series of attacks within DSA on the very leaders – the democratic socialists in Congress – who are the public face of democratic socialism and DSA at this moment;
  • and following from the above, the absence of a strategic perspective which understands how to build power, and the importance of accumulating victories in building power. By strategic perspective, I mean a (Gramscian) understanding of the political terrain on which we struggle, with an analysis and long-term strategy of how to best situate ourselves on that terrain, choosing the battles that we have the best chance of winning and avoiding as much as possible the battles that lead to almost certain political defeat.

6.     Given the above, DSA North Star understands its role in DSA as:
  • developing organizational clarity on the imminent danger of a neo-fascist seizure of political power, and the concomitant loss of American democracy, as the defining feature of our political moment;
  • urging DSA to play a constructive role in organizing a broad center-left coalition to oppose that neo-fascist danger, and to see that as a primary focus of its work;
  • promoting generally within DSA a politics of working in coalition with others on the organizational left and the broad left;
  • opposing attacks on elected officials who are members of DSA and its public face;
  • engendering discussion within DSA of the need for a strategic perspective, and what it might include.
 
 
You are invited to join the dialogue. Use the comments section.

4 Comments
Max B. Sawicky
11/15/2021 12:30:32 pm

I am fully on board with Leo's theses 1-4, and mostly with 5-6. I would propose some additional notes.

DSA has potential because it has the 'democratic socialist' brand, Socialism remains a compelling model, and people joined DSA because of Bernie and AOC, the two most effective progressive politicians in the U.S. These advantages are negated by the current NPC leadership, which is lost in sectarian insurrectionist fantasies, and which channels members into isolated local struggles. To build the popular front of which Leo speaks, this leadership needs to be replaced, or its members need to get their heads screwed on straight.

The North Star caucus punches above its weight in terms of contacts built up over the decades (Yup, we're older than dirt -- LOL) with leaders in other progressive formations. The NPC has street cred -- it is more connected to activism on the ground -- but little political cred, especially insofar as it succumbs to sophomoric complaints about the impurities of successful progressive politicians.

In a nutshell, the North Star caucus has a special role, not to take over DSA, but to elevate younger members who will lead the organization in a more productive direction. As things stand, we are going nowhere. We can continue to get a trickle of new recruits, and we can elect a scattering of members to local offices.

Meanwhile, Neo-Fascism with or without Trump is poised to take over the entire country. If the Republicans retake the Congress next year, all investigations of January 6 will be shut down. Then the stage will be set for the negation of blue states' electoral votes, in the event Democrats' national ticket wins in 2024.

At that point, the U.S. left will be voter-suppressed and gerrymandered completely out of power. Public schools will be beaten down and become incubators of ignorance, racism, and homophobia/transphobia. Street demonstrations will be increasingly curtailed. Educators at both the public school and public university level will be purged. Abuse of immigrants will escalate. Right-wing terrorism will be further indulged (e.g., the Rittenhouse trial, new laws permitting vehicular assault, no legal repercussions for the upper echelons of insurrectionary forces).

There is not a lot of time left for us.



Reply
James A Young link
11/16/2021 12:57:57 am

I agree with Leo on virtually all points and totally with the emphasis on the making of a broad anti-fascist front as the primary thrust of our action. In this effort we may differ on tactics and timing temporarily but we must remain solid on the goal and the determination to demonstrate publicly our unity with and within the coalition for the duration of the struggle against neo-fascism. There's no time to lose.

Reply
Paul Garver
11/16/2021 01:42:03 pm

I like the six theses put forward by Leo Casey.

I would suggest to Max that he not
rush to judgement about the current NPC leadership. The current NPC has only recently been elected, and held its first in-person meeting only in mid-November. I suggest instead reaching out to individual NPC members to hold personal meetings over Zoom.

Reply
Paul J. Baicich
12/28/2021 10:26:50 am

I like Leo Casey's contribution very much, and he covers most of the vital bases... with the need to fight neo-fascism at the core.  Still, I am left asking for more when I read the very last bullet point in the final #6, that North Star's role in DSA means "engendering discussion within DSA of the need for a strategic perspective, and what it might include."

We should be stressing what is a unique socialist potential to break through the "silos" that frequently separate thos who should be our natural allies in this ongoing struggle. Alas, even the best folks in labor, civil rights, feminist, LGBTQ, and environmental organizations seem to revel in their own - and narrower - institutional priorities... to the exclusion of needed alliances. WE can help UNITE to build a left-center (and even, OMG, a center-left) alliance to place us all in a better position in a post mid-term-election America. I ask, how can we - as Leo summarizes - "best situate ourselves on that terrain, choosing the battles that we have the best chance of winning..."? 

I contend it COULD be based - on the domestic scene at least - on the "Biden-Sanders Task Force Recommendations" agreed upon before the last Dem. Convention... as the FLOOR upon which to organize and break through silos. I could be wrong, but that's the starting point for me - the foundational set of priorities upon which to organize a potentially effective anti-neo-fascist threat. 

See here:
https://joebiden.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/UNITY-TASK-FORCE-RECOMMENDATIONS.pdf

Is it enough?  Hell, no. 

But right now, we're not building a vibrant socialist democracy; we're dealing with fighting neo-fascism and the potential to start with a soft social-democratic base. If you start there, you can be in a position to build further... and advance upon any gains made.

And... and James Young wrote in the comments.... "There's no time to lose."

So... there's my three cents!
       
           Paul J. Baicich
           Howard Co, Md.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Principles
    Join Us

    Our Strategy
    Blog
    Twitter
    Facebook

    ​The opinions expressed here are those of members and allies of DSA North Star Caucus meant to educate, inspire discussion and encourage comradely debate.


    RSS Feed


    North Star caucus members

    antiracismdsa (blog of Duane Campbell)

    Hatuey's Ashes (blog of José G. Pérez)

    Authory and Substack of Max Sawicky


    Socialist Education

    Online University of the Left


    Left Periodicals
    Democratic Left
    Socialist Forum
    Washington Socialist
    Jacobin
    In These Times
    Dissent
    Current Affairs
    The Nation
    The American Prospect
    Jewish Currents
    Mother Jones
    The Intercept
    New Politics
    Monthly Review
    n+1
    +972
    The Baffler
    Counterpunch
    Black Agenda Report
    Dollars and Sense


    Comrades
    Organizing Upgrade
    Justice Democrats
    Working Families Party
    Poor People's Campaign
    Committees of Correspondence for Democracy and Socialism
    Progressive Democrats of America
    Our Revolution
    Democracy for America
    MoveOn
    Black Lives Matter
    Movement for Black Lives
    The Women's March
    Jewish Voice for Peace
    J Street
    National Abortion Rights Action League
    ACT UP
    National Organization for Women
    Sunrise
    People's Action
    National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights
    Dream Defenders



Home
Principles
Join Us
About
About DSA
Blog
Contact
© COPYRIGHT 2019. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.